Skip to content

City Overview

Shelter Island, NY

Median List Price
$2,700,000
Active Listings
23

Market

Shelter Island market snapshot

Median price
$2,700,000
Active listings
23
Avg. days on market
126
Price / sq ft
$854

Current Listing Inventory for Shelter Island, NY

Inventory is continuously updated — select a category to view current listings.

Active listings by price range

Number of active listings in Shelter Island, NY by price range
Price RangeListings
$800K-$1M2
Over $1M21

Explore

Explore Shelter Island, NY

For sale

Available homes in Shelter Island

  • For Rent
    26 photos

    $5,000/mo

    4 bd, 2 ba, 2,669 Sq Ft

    12 Dogwood LaneShelter Island, NY 11964#940124

    Single Family Residence10 months

    Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • For Rent
    35 photos

    $75,000/mo

    4 bd, 3.5 ba, 3,800 Sq Ft

    47L S Ferry RoadShelter Island, NY 11964#945334

    Single Family Residence10 months

    Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • Active
    7 photos

    $749,000

    27 Lakeview DriveShelter Island, NY 11964#1063023

    Land12 days

    Listing courtesy of Jason Mitchell Real Estate NY

  • Active
    45 photos

    $1,850,000

    4 bd, 3 ba, 2,600 Sq Ft

    4 Irene LaneShelter Island, NY 11964#1003398

    Single Family Residence5 months

    Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • Active
    13 photos

    $3,250,000

    4 bd, 3 ba, 3,097 Sq Ft

    20 Baldwin RoadShelter Island, NY 11964#1062621

    Single Family Residence2 weeks

    Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • Active
    1 photos

    $1,999,999

    4 bd, 3.5 ba, 2,777 Sq Ft

    5 Marc StShelter Island, NY 11964#1060077

    Single Family Residence2 weeks

    Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Signature Real Estate

  • Active
    28 photos

    $2,800,000

    2 Pandion RoadShelter Island, NY 11964#1055760

    Land2 weeks

    Listing courtesy of Compass Greater NY LLC

  • For Rent
    18 photos

    $86,000/mo

    4 bd, 3.5 ba, 3,484 Sq Ft

    23 Osprey RoadShelter Island, NY 11964#1010703

    Single Family Residence4 months

    Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved
Fair Housing Notice

Local expertise

EXIT Realty offices near Shelter Island

View other cities in New York