Skip to content

5354 New York 23Windham, NY 12496

Greene County

$1,725,000List price
7Beds
8Baths
1,496Sq Ft
1900Year built
0.47Acre lot
13 days agoOn market

Description

Location, income, and opportunity come together in this exceptional mixed-use investment property in the heart of Windham's thriving Main Street business district. Generating over 10,000 in gross monthly rental income, this multifaceted offering includes five fully occupied residential apartments, approximately 1,500 square feet of leased commercial space, and an adjoining .24-acre building lot on a separate tax parcel with access to town sewer and water. With established tenants already in place, this is an attractive turnkey investment with income from day one and exciting potential for future expansion. Ideally positioned in a high-visibility, high-traffic location, the charming Victorian-style main building has been converted to accommodate both commercial and residential uses. The first floor features approximately 1,500 square feet of retail/professional office space with two public bathrooms. A lovely covered front porch adds character and an inviting presence along Main Street. The residential component includes five separate apartments. Upstairs in the Main house are two sunny residences: a two-bedroom, one-bath apartment and a spacious two-bedroom, two-bath apartment with in-unit laundry and access to a private balcony, both with separate entrances. A ground-level side apartment offers one bedroom and one bath. Toward the rear of the property, a converted garage houses two additional one-bedroom, one-bath apartments. All five apartments are occupied, providing an established residential rental income stream. Off-street parking adds convenience, and is connected to municipal water and sewer. And there's more! Included in this offering is an adjoining .24-acre building lot with access to municipal water and sewer hookups. This valuable addition presents an opportunity to expand your Main Street footprint with another mixed-use building, potentially combining commercial and residential space, (subject to municipal approvals) The location couldn't be better! Situated among Windham's shops, restaurants, movie theater, and local businesses, with the school nearby and Windham Mountain Club just one mile away. Windham's four-season appeal, from skiing and golf to hiking, mountain biking, festivals, and year-round recreation, makes this an attractive destination in the Northern Catskills and a beautiful place to live, work and play. Five apartments. Leased commercial space. Over 120,000 in annual gross rental income. An additional .24-acre building lot. One outstanding Main Street investment opportunity.

Property Information

Property type
Residential Income
Sub-type
Multi Family
Structure type
Multi Family / Mixed Use / Office
Year built
1900
Living area
1,496 Sq Ft
Lot size
0.47 acres
Zoning
BR
Days on market
13
MLS® Listing#
20266581

Property Features

Interior
Entrance Foyer · Eat-in Kitchen · High Speed Internet
Appliances
Microwave · Range · Refrigerator · Washer/Dryer
Heating
Baseboard · Electric · Oil
Flooring
Laminate · Linoleum · Wood
Basement
Finished · Interior Entry · Storage Space · Walk-Out Access
Parking
Common · Driveway · Unpaved
Laundry
Laundry Room · In Unit
Patio
Covered · Deck · Front Porch
Lot features
Flag Lot · Level
Construction
Frame
Foundation
Block · Combination · Stone
Roof
Asphalt · Shingle
Windows
Insulated Windows
Security
Carbon Monoxide Detector(s) · Smoke Detector(s)
Other structures
Residence
Utilities
Cable Available · Cable Connected · Electricity Connected · Phone Connected · Sewer Connected · Water Connected
Sewer
Public Sewer
Water source
Public

Financial Details

Annual taxes
$4,019Tax year 2026
Assessed value
$223,500
Parcel number
10.1

Commute Calculator

Explore commute times from 5354 New York 23, Windham, NY 12496.

Travel mode

Connect with a Local Real Estate Expert

  • Jenn Tomlins

    Sales Representative

    EXIT Realty Connections

  • Kathy White

    Sales Representative

    EXIT Realty Connections

  • Donna Jenkins

    Sales Representative

    EXIT Realty Connections