Allegany, NY Real Estate Listings

201 real estate listings match this search criteria near Allegany.

Active
14 photos
$290,000
5 bd, 3 ba, 2,284 Sq Ft
20 Reynolds StreetAlfred, NY 14802#B1719707
Single Family Residence0 days
Active
4 photos
$109,900
4 bd, 1 ba, 1,896 Sq Ft
63 South StreetBolivar, NY 14715#R1719583
Single Family Residence1 day
Active
10 photos
$95,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,044 Sq Ft
105 Scott AvenueWellsville, NY 14895#B1719680
Single Family Residence2 days
Active
50 photos
$710,000
5 bd, 3 ba, 5,500 Sq Ft
1877 Wolf Creek RoadGenesee, NY 14727#B1718456
Single Family Residence3 days
Active
27 photos
$29,000
4 bd, 2 ba, 1,862 Sq Ft
54 Greenwich StreetAmity, NY 14813#R1719264
Single Family Residence3 days
Active
29 photos
$39,900
0.07 acres
7162 Lake RoadBelfast, NY 14711#R1719277
Land3 days
Active
4 photos
$184,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,900 Sq Ft
3472 Sunset DriveWellsville, NY 14895#R1718588
Single Family Residence4 days
Active
11 photos
$34,900
$6,980/acre
5 acres
Lot 3 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718853
Land4 days
Active
32 photos
$59,900
$3,328/acre
18 acres
Lot 01 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718747
Land4 days
Active
50 photos
$129,900
5 bd, 1 ba, 2,760 Sq Ft
1223 Mchenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718403
Single Family Residence5 days
Active
22 photos
$99,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 720 Sq Ft
8195 State Route 417Genesee, NY 14754#B1718215
Mobile Home6 days
Active
11 photos
$105,900
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,243 Sq Ft
86 #hf E Hanover StreetWellsville, NY 14895#R1717921
Single Family Residence6 days
Active
48 photos
$154,900
$32,271/acre
4.8 acres
9173 Lyman Rd & 9448 Valle DrClarksville, NY 14727#B1717596
Cabin6 days
Active
38 photos
$74,900
$14,980/acre
5 acres
9152 Lyman Road 30Clarksville, NY 14727#B1717327
Cabin7 days
Active
45 photos
$229,000
3 bd, 2.5 ba, 2,016 Sq Ft
907 Streeter Brook RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1714066
Manufactured On Land9 days
Active
49 photos
$229,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 2,556 Sq Ft
9045 Farnsworth RoadCuba, NY 14727#B1707357
Single Family Residence9 days
Active
47 photos
$184,000
4 bd, 3 ba, 1,344 Sq Ft
4149 Riverside DriveScio, NY 14813#B1707362
Single Family Residence9 days
Active
37 photos
$364,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,456 Sq Ft
4565 Back River RoadAmity, NY 14813#B1717068
Single Family Residence10 days
Active
50 photos
$219,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,482 Sq Ft
28 Shawmut RoadAngelica, NY 14709#R1717398
Single Family Residence10 days
Active
39 photos
$229,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,840 Sq Ft
57 Powerhouse RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1710697
Single Family Residence10 days
Active
39 photos
$59,000
$3,491/acre
16.9 acres
1235 Kansas Hollow RoadBolivar, NY 14715#R1717438
Agriculture10 days
Active
41 photos
$550,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 840 Sq Ft
8279 Rt-243 BRushford, NY 14777#B1713008
Single Family Residence11 days
Active
24 photos
$179,900
1 bd, 1 ba, 576 Sq Ft
3438 County Road 6Clarksville, NY 14727#B1716916
Single Family Residence12 days
Active
34 photos
$189,000
3 bd, 1 ba, 1,854 Sq Ft
2952 Horseshoe TrailClarksville, NY 14727#B1715073
Single Family Residence12 days

View results from:

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than EXIT Realty, are marked with the IDX logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker’s Firm Name.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is deemed reliable by is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

© 2026 CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS All rights reserved.

Fair Housing Notice

201 real estate listings match this search criteria near Allegany.

Active
14 photos
$290,000
5 bd, 3 ba, 2,284 Sq Ft
20 Reynolds StreetAlfred, NY 14802#B1719707
Single Family Residence0 days
Active
4 photos
$109,900
4 bd, 1 ba, 1,896 Sq Ft
63 South StreetBolivar, NY 14715#R1719583
Single Family Residence1 day
Active
10 photos
$95,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,044 Sq Ft
105 Scott AvenueWellsville, NY 14895#B1719680
Single Family Residence2 days
Active
50 photos
$710,000
5 bd, 3 ba, 5,500 Sq Ft
1877 Wolf Creek RoadGenesee, NY 14727#B1718456
Single Family Residence3 days
Active
27 photos
$29,000
4 bd, 2 ba, 1,862 Sq Ft
54 Greenwich StreetAmity, NY 14813#R1719264
Single Family Residence3 days
Active
29 photos
$39,900
0.07 acres
7162 Lake RoadBelfast, NY 14711#R1719277
Land3 days
Active
4 photos
$184,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,900 Sq Ft
3472 Sunset DriveWellsville, NY 14895#R1718588
Single Family Residence4 days
Active
11 photos
$34,900
$6,980/acre
5 acres
Lot 3 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718853
Land4 days
Active
32 photos
$59,900
$3,328/acre
18 acres
Lot 01 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718747
Land4 days
Active
50 photos
$129,900
5 bd, 1 ba, 2,760 Sq Ft
1223 Mchenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718403
Single Family Residence5 days
Active
22 photos
$99,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 720 Sq Ft
8195 State Route 417Genesee, NY 14754#B1718215
Mobile Home6 days
Active
11 photos
$105,900
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,243 Sq Ft
86 #hf E Hanover StreetWellsville, NY 14895#R1717921
Single Family Residence6 days
Active
48 photos
$154,900
$32,271/acre
4.8 acres
9173 Lyman Rd & 9448 Valle DrClarksville, NY 14727#B1717596
Cabin6 days
Active
38 photos
$74,900
$14,980/acre
5 acres
9152 Lyman Road 30Clarksville, NY 14727#B1717327
Cabin7 days
Active
45 photos
$229,000
3 bd, 2.5 ba, 2,016 Sq Ft
907 Streeter Brook RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1714066
Manufactured On Land9 days
Active
49 photos
$229,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 2,556 Sq Ft
9045 Farnsworth RoadCuba, NY 14727#B1707357
Single Family Residence9 days
Active
47 photos
$184,000
4 bd, 3 ba, 1,344 Sq Ft
4149 Riverside DriveScio, NY 14813#B1707362
Single Family Residence9 days
Active
37 photos
$364,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,456 Sq Ft
4565 Back River RoadAmity, NY 14813#B1717068
Single Family Residence10 days
Active
50 photos
$219,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,482 Sq Ft
28 Shawmut RoadAngelica, NY 14709#R1717398
Single Family Residence10 days
Active
39 photos
$229,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,840 Sq Ft
57 Powerhouse RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1710697
Single Family Residence10 days
Active
39 photos
$59,000
$3,491/acre
16.9 acres
1235 Kansas Hollow RoadBolivar, NY 14715#R1717438
Agriculture10 days
Active
41 photos
$550,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 840 Sq Ft
8279 Rt-243 BRushford, NY 14777#B1713008
Single Family Residence11 days
Active
24 photos
$179,900
1 bd, 1 ba, 576 Sq Ft
3438 County Road 6Clarksville, NY 14727#B1716916
Single Family Residence12 days
Active
34 photos
$189,000
3 bd, 1 ba, 1,854 Sq Ft
2952 Horseshoe TrailClarksville, NY 14727#B1715073
Single Family Residence12 days

View results from:

Fair Housing Notice

Market Overview — Allegany, NY

Showing Allegany, NY

Property type

ResidentialCommercial

Transaction

For SaleFor Lease

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

$199,000
Median Listing Price: 52
Median Days on EXIT Realty: 2,048
Median Sq Ft: $72
Median Price per Sq Ft

Compare

Compare Allegany, NY to another area

Median price, days on market and size comparison by area
Area	Median Listing Price	Median Days on EXIT Realty	Median Sq Ft	Median Price per Sq Ft	Actions
Allegany, NY	$199,000	52	2,048	$72

Market Composition

What's on the market

57%Land16 active
39%Residential11 active
4%Commercial1 active

Active listings by price

Under $200K55% · 6
$200K-$400K27% · 3
Over $1M18% · 2

Median Price Trend

Aug 2026: $242,500 +11.3%Oct 2026: $269,900

Thinking of selling?

EXIT Realty’s Allegany agents know these numbers street by street — and bring the insight and negotiating experience to turn them into your sale price.

Sell a home in Allegany

Nearby Schools

Elementary 10

Allegany Limestone Elementary School
Allegany, NY · 0.4 mi away
Washington West Elementary School
Olean, NY · 2.6 mi away
Montessori Children's House of Olean
Olean, NY · 3.2 mi away
New Life Christian School
Olean, NY · 3.2 mi away
Olean Intermediate-Middle School
Olean, NY · 3.3 mi away
Ivers J Norton Elementary School
Olean, NY · 3.4 mi away
Boardmanville Elementary School
Olean, NY · 3.6 mi away
East View Elementary School
Olean, NY · 4.3 mi away
Limestone Campus Elementary School
Limestone, NY · 8.1 mi away
Portville Central School District
Portville, NY · 9.4 mi away

Secondary 3

Allegany Limestone Central School
Allegany, NY · 2.8 mi away
Olean High School
Olean, NY · 3.3 mi away
Portville Junior/Senior High School
Portville, NY · 9.4 mi away

Other schools 7

Maple Street Academy
Olean, NY · 3.2 mi away
Olean City School District
Olean, NY · 3.3 mi away
Southern Tier Catholic School
Olean, NY · 3.6 mi away
Cattaraugus-Allegany-Erie-Wyoming Boces
Olean, NY · 4.7 mi away
Hinsdale Central School
Hinsdale, NY · 7.1 mi away
Portville Baptist Church
Portville, NY · 8.9 mi away
Portville Central School District
Portville, NY · 9.4 mi away

Allegany, NY Real Estate Listings

Allegany, NY Real Estate Listings

20 Reynolds StreetAlfred, NY 14802#B1719707

63 South StreetBolivar, NY 14715#R1719583

105 Scott AvenueWellsville, NY 14895#B1719680

1877 Wolf Creek RoadGenesee, NY 14727#B1718456

54 Greenwich StreetAmity, NY 14813#R1719264

7162 Lake RoadBelfast, NY 14711#R1719277

3472 Sunset DriveWellsville, NY 14895#R1718588

Lot 3 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718853

Lot 01 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718747

1223 Mchenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718403

8195 State Route 417Genesee, NY 14754#B1718215

86 #hf E Hanover StreetWellsville, NY 14895#R1717921

9173 Lyman Rd & 9448 Valle DrClarksville, NY 14727#B1717596

9152 Lyman Road 30Clarksville, NY 14727#B1717327

907 Streeter Brook RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1714066

9045 Farnsworth RoadCuba, NY 14727#B1707357

4149 Riverside DriveScio, NY 14813#B1707362

4565 Back River RoadAmity, NY 14813#B1717068

28 Shawmut RoadAngelica, NY 14709#R1717398

57 Powerhouse RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1710697

1235 Kansas Hollow RoadBolivar, NY 14715#R1717438

8279 Rt-243 BRushford, NY 14777#B1713008

3438 County Road 6Clarksville, NY 14727#B1716916

2952 Horseshoe TrailClarksville, NY 14727#B1715073

20 Reynolds StreetAlfred, NY 14802#B1719707

63 South StreetBolivar, NY 14715#R1719583

105 Scott AvenueWellsville, NY 14895#B1719680

1877 Wolf Creek RoadGenesee, NY 14727#B1718456

54 Greenwich StreetAmity, NY 14813#R1719264

7162 Lake RoadBelfast, NY 14711#R1719277

3472 Sunset DriveWellsville, NY 14895#R1718588

Lot 3 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718853

Lot 01 McHenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718747

1223 Mchenry Valley RoadAlmond, NY 14804#R1718403

8195 State Route 417Genesee, NY 14754#B1718215

86 #hf E Hanover StreetWellsville, NY 14895#R1717921

9173 Lyman Rd & 9448 Valle DrClarksville, NY 14727#B1717596

9152 Lyman Road 30Clarksville, NY 14727#B1717327

907 Streeter Brook RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1714066

9045 Farnsworth RoadCuba, NY 14727#B1707357

4149 Riverside DriveScio, NY 14813#B1707362

4565 Back River RoadAmity, NY 14813#B1717068

28 Shawmut RoadAngelica, NY 14709#R1717398

57 Powerhouse RoadGenesee, NY 14754#B1710697

1235 Kansas Hollow RoadBolivar, NY 14715#R1717438

8279 Rt-243 BRushford, NY 14777#B1713008

3438 County Road 6Clarksville, NY 14727#B1716916

2952 Horseshoe TrailClarksville, NY 14727#B1715073

Market Overview — Allegany, NY

Area Average

Compare

Market Composition

What's on the market

Active listings by price

Median Price Trend

Nearby Schools

Elementary 10

Secondary 3

Other schools 7