Butternuts, NY Real Estate Listings

11 real estate listings match this search criteria near Butternuts.

Active
50 photos
$499,000
4 bd, 3.5 ba, 2,736 Sq Ft
1593 Butternut RoadButternuts, NY 13849#R1713431
Single Family Residence8 days
Active
41 photos
$399,000
3 bd, 1 ba, 2,772 Sq Ft
334 Lulu Coon RoadButternuts, NY 13776#R1710878
Single Family Residence5 weeks
Active
7 photos
$59,900
3 bd, 1 ba, 1,708 Sq Ft
6 Elm StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1709232
Single Family Residence6 weeks
Active
37 photos
$249,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,609 Sq Ft
1691 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13808#R1705748
Single Family Residence7 weeks
Active
37 photos
$250,000
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,904 Sq Ft
1568 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13776#R1688089
Single Family Residence3 months
Active
4 photos
$36,000
$6,250/acre
5.76 acres
0 County Highway 4Butternuts, NY 13776#R1684439
Agriculture4 months
Active
24 photos
$54,000
$284,211/acre
0.19 acres
1564 State Highway 8Guilford, NY 13809#R1681660
Cabin4 months
Active
17 photos
$199,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,848 Sq Ft
1136 County Highway 8Butternuts, NY 13808#R1669672
Single Family Residence5 months
Active
28 photos
$495,000
5 bd, 2 ba, 2,400 Sq Ft
3 Cliff StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1688489
Single Family Residence3 months
Active
40 photos
$435,000
2 bd, 1.5 ba, 2,016 Sq Ft
215 Oppermann RoadButternuts, NY 13843#R1706915
Single Family Residence7 weeks
Active
7 photos
$249,000
5 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,480 Sq Ft
3036 County Highway 4Call Listing Agent, NY 13776#1027919
Single Family Residence10 weeks
Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties

View results from:

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than EXIT Realty, are marked with the IDX logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker’s Firm Name.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is deemed reliable by is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

© 2026 CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS All rights reserved.

Fair Housing Notice

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

Fair Housing Notice

11 real estate listings match this search criteria near Butternuts.

Active
50 photos
$499,000
4 bd, 3.5 ba, 2,736 Sq Ft
1593 Butternut RoadButternuts, NY 13849#R1713431
Single Family Residence8 days
Active
41 photos
$399,000
3 bd, 1 ba, 2,772 Sq Ft
334 Lulu Coon RoadButternuts, NY 13776#R1710878
Single Family Residence5 weeks
Active
7 photos
$59,900
3 bd, 1 ba, 1,708 Sq Ft
6 Elm StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1709232
Single Family Residence6 weeks
Active
37 photos
$249,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,609 Sq Ft
1691 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13808#R1705748
Single Family Residence7 weeks
Active
37 photos
$250,000
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,904 Sq Ft
1568 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13776#R1688089
Single Family Residence3 months
Active
4 photos
$36,000
$6,250/acre
5.76 acres
0 County Highway 4Butternuts, NY 13776#R1684439
Agriculture4 months
Active
24 photos
$54,000
$284,211/acre
0.19 acres
1564 State Highway 8Guilford, NY 13809#R1681660
Cabin4 months
Active
17 photos
$199,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,848 Sq Ft
1136 County Highway 8Butternuts, NY 13808#R1669672
Single Family Residence5 months
Active
28 photos
$495,000
5 bd, 2 ba, 2,400 Sq Ft
3 Cliff StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1688489
Single Family Residence3 months
Active
40 photos
$435,000
2 bd, 1.5 ba, 2,016 Sq Ft
215 Oppermann RoadButternuts, NY 13843#R1706915
Single Family Residence7 weeks
Active
7 photos
$249,000
5 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,480 Sq Ft
3036 County Highway 4Call Listing Agent, NY 13776#1027919
Single Family Residence10 weeks
Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties

View results from:

Fair Housing Notice

Market Overview — Butternuts, NY

Showing Butternuts, NY

Property type

ResidentialCommercial

Transaction

For SaleFor Lease

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

$250,000
Median Listing Price: 53
Median Days on EXIT Realty: 1,904
Median Sq Ft: $156
Median Price per Sq Ft

Compare

Compare Butternuts, NY to another area

Median price, days on market and size comparison by area
Area	Median Listing Price	Median Days on EXIT Realty	Median Sq Ft	Median Price per Sq Ft	Actions
Butternuts, NY	$250,000	53	1,904	$156

Market Composition

What's on the market

75%Residential9 active
25%Land3 active

Active listings by price

Under $200K22% · 2
$200K-$400K44% · 4
$400K-$600K33% · 3

Thinking of selling?

EXIT Realty’s Butternuts agents know these numbers street by street — and bring the insight and negotiating experience to turn them into your sale price.

Sell a home in Butternuts

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Otego Elementary School
Otego, NY · 5.6 mi away
Greater Plains Elementary School
Oneonta, NY · 8.7 mi away
Unadilla Elementary School
Unadilla, NY · 9.1 mi away
Riverside Elementary School
Oneonta, NY · 9.6 mi away
Center Street Elementary School
Oneonta, NY · 9.8 mi away
Valleyview Elementary School
Oneonta, NY · 10.8 mi away
Sidney Center Elementary School
Unadilla, NY · 10.8 mi away
Sidney Elementary School
Sidney, NY · 12.1 mi away

Secondary 5

Unatego Middle School
Otego, NY · 5.8 mi away
Unatego Junior Senior High School
Otego, NY · 5.8 mi away
Oneonta Job Corps
Oneonta, NY · 9.7 mi away
Oneonta Senior High School
Oneonta, NY · 10.4 mi away
Sidney Middle School
Sidney, NY · 12.1 mi away

Other schools 7

Morris Central School
Morris, NY · 6.6 mi away
Franklin Central School
Franklin, NY · 9.1 mi away
Oneonta Community Christian School
Oneonta, NY · 9.1 mi away
Oneonta City School District
Oneonta, NY · 9.8 mi away
Wilber Hall
Oneonta, NY · 10.0 mi away
Laurens Central School
Laurens, NY · 10.2 mi away
Tri-Town Nursery School
Sidney, NY · 11.6 mi away

Butternuts, NY Real Estate Listings

Butternuts, NY Real Estate Listings

1593 Butternut RoadButternuts, NY 13849#R1713431

334 Lulu Coon RoadButternuts, NY 13776#R1710878

6 Elm StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1709232

1691 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13808#R1705748

1568 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13776#R1688089

0 County Highway 4Butternuts, NY 13776#R1684439

1564 State Highway 8Guilford, NY 13809#R1681660

1136 County Highway 8Butternuts, NY 13808#R1669672

3 Cliff StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1688489

215 Oppermann RoadButternuts, NY 13843#R1706915

3036 County Highway 4Call Listing Agent, NY 13776#1027919

1593 Butternut RoadButternuts, NY 13849#R1713431

334 Lulu Coon RoadButternuts, NY 13776#R1710878

6 Elm StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1709232

1691 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13808#R1705748

1568 State Highway 51Butternuts, NY 13776#R1688089

0 County Highway 4Butternuts, NY 13776#R1684439

1564 State Highway 8Guilford, NY 13809#R1681660

1136 County Highway 8Butternuts, NY 13808#R1669672

3 Cliff StreetButternuts, NY 13776#R1688489

215 Oppermann RoadButternuts, NY 13843#R1706915

3036 County Highway 4Call Listing Agent, NY 13776#1027919

Market Overview — Butternuts, NY

Area Average

Compare

Market Composition

What's on the market

Active listings by price

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Secondary 5

Other schools 7