Chautauqua, NY Real Estate Listings

63 real estate listings match this search criteria near Chautauqua.

Active
9 photos
$299,900
1,820 Sq Ft
1058 Rt 394Poland, NY 14747#R1716953
Commercial Sale3 days
Active
49 photos
$140,000
4,060 Sq Ft
1175, 1173, 1171 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1712342
Mixed Use4 weeks
Active
27 photos
$264,000
3,264 Sq Ft
510 Central AvenueDunkirk, NY 14048#R1697611
Office7 weeks
Active
50 photos
$989,000
4,400 Sq Ft
4957 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1699429
Commercial Sale11 weeks
Active
24 photos
$189,000
5,956 Sq Ft
3990 Falconer Kimball Stand RoadEllicott, NY 14733#R1687118
Mixed Use3 months
Active
29 photos
$159,000
1,824 Sq Ft
4005 N Main Street ExtensionGerry, NY 14701#R1691393
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
25 photos
$99,900
13,000 Sq Ft
6795 Depot StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1680969
Business4 months
Active
22 photos
$175,000
5,447 Sq Ft
808 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1666849
Apartment6 months
Active
33 photos
$239,000
2,660 Sq Ft
57 Temple StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1664400
Office7 months
Active
45 photos
$174,900
8,832 Sq Ft
4492 Church StreetGerry, NY 14740#R1661776
Commercial Sale7 months
Active
26 photos
$150,000
1,320 Sq Ft
34 White StreetPomfret, NY 14063#B1662228
Office7 months
Active
47 photos
$299,900
4,300 Sq Ft
33-35 E Main StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1639256
Office12 months
Active
24 photos
$59,000
2,272 Sq Ft
6837 Main StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1612862
Commercial Sale15 months
Active
11 photos
$81,900
870 Sq Ft
359 Lake Shore Drive EastDunkirk, NY 14048#R1679322
Commercial Sale5 months
Active
47 photos
$849,900
2,226 Sq Ft
15 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1691513
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
38 photos
$1,800,000
3,632 Sq Ft
10661 W Lake RoadRipley, NY 14775#B1674113
Commercial Sale5 months
Active
33 photos
$209,900
3,695 Sq Ft
509 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1690344
Office3 months
Active
2 photos
$115,000
0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691589
Business3 months
Active
6 photos
$130,000
0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691568
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
5 photos
$849,000
1,152 Sq Ft
196 E Fairmount AvenueBusti, NY 14750#R1684206
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
24 photos
$499,950
14,976 Sq Ft
3771 E Main RoadPomfret, NY 14063#R1687308
Commercial Sale4 months
Active
16 photos
$299,900
7,260 Sq Ft
309 Prendergast AvenueJamestown, NY 14701#R1688205
Business4 months
Active
50 photos
$550,000
28,452 Sq Ft
9 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1689451
Mixed Use3 months
Active
22 photos
$399,000
3,569 Sq Ft
1203 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1686580
Industrial4 months

View results from:

The EXIT Realty office serving this area’s listings is EXIT Turning Key Realty.

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than EXIT Realty, are marked with the IDX logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker’s Firm Name.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is deemed reliable by is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

© 2026 CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS All rights reserved.

Fair Housing Notice

63 real estate listings match this search criteria near Chautauqua.

Active
9 photos
$299,900
1,820 Sq Ft
1058 Rt 394Poland, NY 14747#R1716953
Commercial Sale3 days
Active
49 photos
$140,000
4,060 Sq Ft
1175, 1173, 1171 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1712342
Mixed Use4 weeks
Active
27 photos
$264,000
3,264 Sq Ft
510 Central AvenueDunkirk, NY 14048#R1697611
Office7 weeks
Active
50 photos
$989,000
4,400 Sq Ft
4957 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1699429
Commercial Sale11 weeks
Active
24 photos
$189,000
5,956 Sq Ft
3990 Falconer Kimball Stand RoadEllicott, NY 14733#R1687118
Mixed Use3 months
Active
29 photos
$159,000
1,824 Sq Ft
4005 N Main Street ExtensionGerry, NY 14701#R1691393
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
25 photos
$99,900
13,000 Sq Ft
6795 Depot StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1680969
Business4 months
Active
22 photos
$175,000
5,447 Sq Ft
808 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1666849
Apartment6 months
Active
33 photos
$239,000
2,660 Sq Ft
57 Temple StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1664400
Office7 months
Active
45 photos
$174,900
8,832 Sq Ft
4492 Church StreetGerry, NY 14740#R1661776
Commercial Sale7 months
Active
26 photos
$150,000
1,320 Sq Ft
34 White StreetPomfret, NY 14063#B1662228
Office7 months
Active
47 photos
$299,900
4,300 Sq Ft
33-35 E Main StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1639256
Office12 months
Active
24 photos
$59,000
2,272 Sq Ft
6837 Main StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1612862
Commercial Sale15 months
Active
11 photos
$81,900
870 Sq Ft
359 Lake Shore Drive EastDunkirk, NY 14048#R1679322
Commercial Sale5 months
Active
47 photos
$849,900
2,226 Sq Ft
15 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1691513
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
38 photos
$1,800,000
3,632 Sq Ft
10661 W Lake RoadRipley, NY 14775#B1674113
Commercial Sale5 months
Active
33 photos
$209,900
3,695 Sq Ft
509 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1690344
Office3 months
Active
2 photos
$115,000
0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691589
Business3 months
Active
6 photos
$130,000
0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691568
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
5 photos
$849,000
1,152 Sq Ft
196 E Fairmount AvenueBusti, NY 14750#R1684206
Commercial Sale3 months
Active
24 photos
$499,950
14,976 Sq Ft
3771 E Main RoadPomfret, NY 14063#R1687308
Commercial Sale4 months
Active
16 photos
$299,900
7,260 Sq Ft
309 Prendergast AvenueJamestown, NY 14701#R1688205
Business4 months
Active
50 photos
$550,000
28,452 Sq Ft
9 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1689451
Mixed Use3 months
Active
22 photos
$399,000
3,569 Sq Ft
1203 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1686580
Industrial4 months

View results from:

The EXIT Realty office serving this area’s listings is EXIT Turning Key Realty.

Fair Housing Notice

Market Overview — Chautauqua, NY

Showing Chautauqua, NY

Property type

ResidentialCommercial

Transaction

For SaleFor Lease

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

$426,950
Median Listing Price: 109
Median Days on EXIT Realty: 1,923
Median Sq Ft: $209
Median Price per Sq Ft

Compare

Compare Chautauqua, NY to another area

Median price, days on market and size comparison by area
Area	Median Listing Price	Median Days on EXIT Realty	Median Sq Ft	Median Price per Sq Ft	Actions
Chautauqua, NY	$426,950	109	1,923	$209

Market Composition

What's on the market

49%Land28 active
42%Residential24 active
4%Commercial Lease2 active
4%Commercial2 active
2%For Lease1 active

Active listings by price

Under $200K25% · 6
$200K-$400K25% · 6
$400K-$600K29% · 7
$600K-$800K13% · 3
$800K-$1M4% · 1
Over $1M4% · 1

Median Price Trend

Sep 2026: $270,000 +33%Oct 2026: $359,000

Thinking of selling?

EXIT Realty’s Chautauqua agents know these numbers street by street — and bring the insight and negotiating experience to turn them into your sale price.

Sell a home in Chautauqua

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Brocton Elementary School
Brocton, NY · 6.3 mi away
Sinclairville Elementary School
Sinclairville, NY · 7.6 mi away
Bemus Point Central School District
Bemus Point, NY · 9.6 mi away
Fredonia Central School District
Fredonia, NY · 10.1 mi away
Bemus Point Central School District
Bemus Point, NY · 10.2 mi away
School No. 4
Dunkirk, NY · 12.7 mi away
School 3
Dunkirk, NY · 13.0 mi away
Dunkirk Middle School
Dunkirk, NY · 13.0 mi away

Secondary 5

Chautauqua Lake Central School
Mayville, NY · 6.3 mi away
Brocton Middle High School
Brocton, NY · 6.3 mi away
Cassadaga Valley Central School
Sinclairville, NY · 7.0 mi away
Maple Grove Junior Senior High School
Jamestown, NY · 10.4 mi away
Dunkirk City School District
Dunkirk, NY · 12.8 mi away

Post-secondary 1

Suny Empire State College Fredonia
Fredonia, NY · 10.2 mi away

Other schools 6

Chautauqua County Ems Education Division
Mayville, NY · 6.2 mi away
Fredonia Baptist Nursery School
Fredonia, NY · 10.1 mi away
Buffalo Hearing & Speech Center
Fredonia, NY · 10.1 mi away
Central Christian Academy
Dunkirk, NY · 12.4 mi away
First Baptist Church
Dunkirk, NY · 12.4 mi away
School Number 4
Dunkirk, NY · 12.7 mi away

Chautauqua, NY Real Estate Listings

Chautauqua, NY Real Estate Listings

1058 Rt 394Poland, NY 14747#R1716953

1175, 1173, 1171 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1712342

510 Central AvenueDunkirk, NY 14048#R1697611

4957 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1699429

3990 Falconer Kimball Stand RoadEllicott, NY 14733#R1687118

4005 N Main Street ExtensionGerry, NY 14701#R1691393

6795 Depot StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1680969

808 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1666849

57 Temple StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1664400

4492 Church StreetGerry, NY 14740#R1661776

34 White StreetPomfret, NY 14063#B1662228

33-35 E Main StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1639256

6837 Main StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1612862

359 Lake Shore Drive EastDunkirk, NY 14048#R1679322

15 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1691513

10661 W Lake RoadRipley, NY 14775#B1674113

509 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1690344

0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691589

0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691568

196 E Fairmount AvenueBusti, NY 14750#R1684206

3771 E Main RoadPomfret, NY 14063#R1687308

309 Prendergast AvenueJamestown, NY 14701#R1688205

9 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1689451

1203 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1686580

1058 Rt 394Poland, NY 14747#R1716953

1175, 1173, 1171 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1712342

510 Central AvenueDunkirk, NY 14048#R1697611

4957 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1699429

3990 Falconer Kimball Stand RoadEllicott, NY 14733#R1687118

4005 N Main Street ExtensionGerry, NY 14701#R1691393

6795 Depot StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1680969

808 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1666849

57 Temple StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1664400

4492 Church StreetGerry, NY 14740#R1661776

34 White StreetPomfret, NY 14063#B1662228

33-35 E Main StreetPomfret, NY 14063#R1639256

6837 Main StreetCherry Creek, NY 14723#R1612862

359 Lake Shore Drive EastDunkirk, NY 14048#R1679322

15 Main StreetEllery, NY 14712#R1691513

10661 W Lake RoadRipley, NY 14775#B1674113

509 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1690344

0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691589

0 East Main St ExtensionEllicott, NY 14733#R1691568

196 E Fairmount AvenueBusti, NY 14750#R1684206

3771 E Main RoadPomfret, NY 14063#R1687308

309 Prendergast AvenueJamestown, NY 14701#R1688205

9 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1689451

1203 N Main StreetJamestown, NY 14701#R1686580

Market Overview — Chautauqua, NY

Area Average

Compare

Market Composition

What's on the market

Active listings by price

Median Price Trend

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Secondary 5

Post-secondary 1

Other schools 6