Montello, WI Real Estate Listings

17 real estate listings match this search criteria near Montello.

Active
36 photos
$275,000
16 bd, 6 ba
497B Lake St StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004573
Multi Family14 months
Active
72 photos
$575,000
16 bd, 6 ba
497 S Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#1999848
Multi Family16 months
Active
72 photos
$299,900
8 bd, 3 ba, 4,000 Sq Ft
497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013831
Single Family Residence9 months
Active
28 photos
$299,900
8 bd, 3 ba
497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004572
Multi Family14 months
Active
72 photos
$275,000
8 bd, 3 ba, 4,000 Sq Ft
497B Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013832
Single Family Residence9 months
Active
1 photos
$24,500
$102,083/acre
0.24 acres, Zoned Res
130 E Montello StreetMontello, WI 53949#2033825
Land4 days
Active
1 photos
$34,500
$43,671/acre
0.79 acres, Zoned residentia
Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2001137
Land16 months
Active
5 photos
$69,900
$122,632/acre
0.57 acres, Zoned Res
.57 Ac Water StreetMontello, WI 53949#1855894
Land90 months
Active
8 photos
$29,900
$23,730/acre
1.26 acres, Zoned RES
Lot 1 Woodland AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2032124
Land4 weeks
Active
13 photos
$35,000
$38,043/acre
0.92 acres, Zoned AG-3
Lot 53, 3rd AvenueOxford, WI 53952#1974950
Land30 months
Active
1 photos
$29,900
$37,375/acre
0.8 acres, Zoned R-1
Lot 47 FernMontello, WI 53949#1983985
Land26 months
Active
1 photos
$487,699
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,780 Sq Ft
Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2025150
Single Family Residence4 months
Active
7 photos
$245,900
4 bd, 2 ba
246 Clay StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013259
Multi Family10 months
Active
37 photos
$375,000
567 Underwood AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2028785
Business10 weeks
Active
19 photos
$349,000
3 bd, 3 ba, 1,900 Sq Ft
328 Brooke CircleMontello, WI 53949#2033142
Single Family Residence13 days
Active
71 photos
$359,900
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,700 Sq Ft
117 S Main StreetMontello, WI 53949#2031916
Single Family Residence4 weeks
Active
20 photos
$65,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 1,400 Sq Ft
147 Douglas AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2033964
Single Family Residence1 day

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Display program of the South Central Wisconsin MLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than EXIT Realty are marked with the 'MLS' icon and/or include the name of the listing broker. This information, provided by seller, listing broker, and other parties, may not have been verified. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 South Central Wisconsin MLS. All Rights Reserved.

17 real estate listings match this search criteria near Montello.

Active
36 photos
$275,000
16 bd, 6 ba
497B Lake St StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004573
Multi Family14 months
Active
72 photos
$575,000
16 bd, 6 ba
497 S Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#1999848
Multi Family16 months
Active
72 photos
$299,900
8 bd, 3 ba, 4,000 Sq Ft
497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013831
Single Family Residence9 months
Active
28 photos
$299,900
8 bd, 3 ba
497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004572
Multi Family14 months
Active
72 photos
$275,000
8 bd, 3 ba, 4,000 Sq Ft
497B Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013832
Single Family Residence9 months
Active
1 photos
$24,500
$102,083/acre
0.24 acres, Zoned Res
130 E Montello StreetMontello, WI 53949#2033825
Land4 days
Active
1 photos
$34,500
$43,671/acre
0.79 acres, Zoned residentia
Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2001137
Land16 months
Active
5 photos
$69,900
$122,632/acre
0.57 acres, Zoned Res
.57 Ac Water StreetMontello, WI 53949#1855894
Land90 months
Active
8 photos
$29,900
$23,730/acre
1.26 acres, Zoned RES
Lot 1 Woodland AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2032124
Land4 weeks
Active
13 photos
$35,000
$38,043/acre
0.92 acres, Zoned AG-3
Lot 53, 3rd AvenueOxford, WI 53952#1974950
Land30 months
Active
1 photos
$29,900
$37,375/acre
0.8 acres, Zoned R-1
Lot 47 FernMontello, WI 53949#1983985
Land26 months
Active
1 photos
$487,699
3 bd, 2 ba, 1,780 Sq Ft
Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2025150
Single Family Residence4 months
Active
7 photos
$245,900
4 bd, 2 ba
246 Clay StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013259
Multi Family10 months
Active
37 photos
$375,000
567 Underwood AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2028785
Business10 weeks
Active
19 photos
$349,000
3 bd, 3 ba, 1,900 Sq Ft
328 Brooke CircleMontello, WI 53949#2033142
Single Family Residence13 days
Active
71 photos
$359,900
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,700 Sq Ft
117 S Main StreetMontello, WI 53949#2031916
Single Family Residence4 weeks
Active
20 photos
$65,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 1,400 Sq Ft
147 Douglas AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2033964
Single Family Residence1 day

Market Overview — Montello, WI

Showing Montello, WI

Property type

ResidentialCommercial

Transaction

For SaleFor Lease

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

$300,000
Median Listing Price: 100
Median Days on EXIT Realty: 1,500
Median Sq Ft: $195
Median Price per Sq Ft

Compare

Compare Montello, WI to another area

Median price, days on market and size comparison by area
Area	Median Listing Price	Median Days on EXIT Realty	Median Sq Ft	Median Price per Sq Ft	Actions
Montello, WI	$300,000	100	1,500	$195

Market Composition

What's on the market

52%Residential33 active
34%Land22 active
6%Multi-Family4 active
3%Commercial2 active
3%Farm2 active
2%For Lease1 active

Active listings by price

Under $200K19% · 7
$200K-$400K54% · 20
$400K-$600K22% · 8
$600K-$800K3% · 1
$800K-$1M3% · 1

Median Price Trend

Sep 2026: $130,000 +134.6%Oct 2026: $305,000

Thinking of selling?

EXIT Realty’s Montello agents know these numbers street by street — and bring the insight and negotiating experience to turn them into your sale price.

Sell a home in Montello

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Montello School District
Montello, WI · 0.5 mi away
Forest Lane Elementary School
Montello, WI · 0.5 mi away
Endeavor Elementary School
Endeavor, WI · 8.8 mi away
Westfield Elementary School
Westfield, WI · 10.1 mi away
Oxford Elementary School
Oxford, WI · 12.1 mi away
Woodridge Primary School
Portage, WI · 17.4 mi away
Portage Community School District
Portage, WI · 17.5 mi away
John Muir Elementary School
Portage, WI · 17.5 mi away

Secondary 5

Montello Jr Sr High School
Montello, WI · 0.5 mi away
Westfield Area High
Westfield, WI · 10.7 mi away
Portage High School
Portage, WI · 17.2 mi away
Portage Junior High School
Portage, WI · 17.5 mi away
Columbia Correctional Institution
Portage, WI · 17.5 mi away

Other schools 7

St John's Lutheran School
Montello, WI · 0.6 mi away
St John-Baptist Catholic School
Princeton, WI · 10.2 mi away
Resurrection Lutheran School
Westfield, WI · 10.2 mi away
Princeton School
Princeton, WI · 11.0 mi away
Rocky Ridge School
Dalton, WI · 13.0 mi away
Faith Lutheran School
Markesan, WI · 16.6 mi away
Cesa 5
Portage, WI · 17.3 mi away

Montello, WI Real Estate Listings

Montello, WI Real Estate Listings

497B Lake St StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004573

497 S Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#1999848

497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013831

497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004572

497B Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013832

130 E Montello StreetMontello, WI 53949#2033825

Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2001137

.57 Ac Water StreetMontello, WI 53949#1855894

Lot 1 Woodland AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2032124

Lot 53, 3rd AvenueOxford, WI 53952#1974950

Lot 47 FernMontello, WI 53949#1983985

Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2025150

246 Clay StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013259

567 Underwood AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2028785

328 Brooke CircleMontello, WI 53949#2033142

117 S Main StreetMontello, WI 53949#2031916

147 Douglas AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2033964

497B Lake St StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004573

497 S Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#1999848

497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013831

497A Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2004572

497B Lake StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013832

130 E Montello StreetMontello, WI 53949#2033825

Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2001137

.57 Ac Water StreetMontello, WI 53949#1855894

Lot 1 Woodland AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2032124

Lot 53, 3rd AvenueOxford, WI 53952#1974950

Lot 47 FernMontello, WI 53949#1983985

Lot 59 Fern AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2025150

246 Clay StreetMontello, WI 53949#2013259

567 Underwood AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2028785

328 Brooke CircleMontello, WI 53949#2033142

117 S Main StreetMontello, WI 53949#2031916

147 Douglas AvenueMontello, WI 53949#2033964

Market Overview — Montello, WI

Area Average

Compare

Market Composition

What's on the market

Active listings by price

Median Price Trend

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Secondary 5

Other schools 7