Shelby, NY Real Estate Listings

15 real estate listings match this search criteria near Shelby.

Active
47 photos
$549,000
4 bd, 2.5 ba, 2,801 Sq Ft
4095 Taylor Hill RoadAlbion, NY 14411#B1719364
Single Family Residence2 days
Active
42 photos
$259,900
2 bd, 1 ba, 1,208 Sq Ft
1207 S Main StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1718780
Single Family Residence4 days
Active
50 photos
$189,900
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,482 Sq Ft
706 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1691908
Single Family Residence12 days
Active
50 photos
$390,000
6 bd, 3 ba, 3,288 Sq Ft
916 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1714478
Single Family Residence2 weeks
Active
28 photos
$159,000
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,680 Sq Ft
1209 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1713482
Single Family Residence3 weeks
Active
14 photos
$48,900
2 bd, 1 ba, 720 Sq Ft
19 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1711410
Manufactured Home4 weeks
Active
39 photos
$325,000
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,600 Sq Ft
11024 Furness ParkwayShelby, NY 14103#R1708335
Single Family Residence6 weeks
Active
19 photos
$148,900
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,402 Sq Ft
580 East AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1701934
Single Family Residence9 weeks
Active
40 photos
$299,000
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 2,034 Sq Ft
1340 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1698458
Single Family Residence11 weeks
Active
11 photos
$138,000
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,470 Sq Ft
362 South AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1668904
Single Family Residence6 months
Active
17 photos
$69,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 980 Sq Ft
60 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1690801
Manufactured Home3 months
Active
2 photos
$34,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 960 Sq Ft
15 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#R1702828
Manufactured Home9 weeks
Active
35 photos
$115,000
2 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,208 Sq Ft
429 E Oak Orchard StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1712248
Single Family Residence4 weeks
Active
17 photos
$169,900
$89,421/acre
1.9 acres
4050 Hoffman RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1712306
Unimproved Land4 weeks
Active
11 photos
$59,900
$19,967/acre
3 acres
4020 B Salt Works RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1694973
Land11 weeks

View results from:

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than EXIT Realty, are marked with the IDX logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker’s Firm Name.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is deemed reliable by is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

© 2026 CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS All rights reserved.

Fair Housing Notice

15 real estate listings match this search criteria near Shelby.

Active
47 photos
$549,000
4 bd, 2.5 ba, 2,801 Sq Ft
4095 Taylor Hill RoadAlbion, NY 14411#B1719364
Single Family Residence2 days
Active
42 photos
$259,900
2 bd, 1 ba, 1,208 Sq Ft
1207 S Main StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1718780
Single Family Residence4 days
Active
50 photos
$189,900
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,482 Sq Ft
706 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1691908
Single Family Residence12 days
Active
50 photos
$390,000
6 bd, 3 ba, 3,288 Sq Ft
916 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1714478
Single Family Residence2 weeks
Active
28 photos
$159,000
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,680 Sq Ft
1209 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1713482
Single Family Residence3 weeks
Active
14 photos
$48,900
2 bd, 1 ba, 720 Sq Ft
19 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1711410
Manufactured Home4 weeks
Active
39 photos
$325,000
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,600 Sq Ft
11024 Furness ParkwayShelby, NY 14103#R1708335
Single Family Residence6 weeks
Active
19 photos
$148,900
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,402 Sq Ft
580 East AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1701934
Single Family Residence9 weeks
Active
40 photos
$299,000
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 2,034 Sq Ft
1340 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1698458
Single Family Residence11 weeks
Active
11 photos
$138,000
3 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,470 Sq Ft
362 South AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1668904
Single Family Residence6 months
Active
17 photos
$69,900
3 bd, 2 ba, 980 Sq Ft
60 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1690801
Manufactured Home3 months
Active
2 photos
$34,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 960 Sq Ft
15 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#R1702828
Manufactured Home9 weeks
Active
35 photos
$115,000
2 bd, 1.5 ba, 1,208 Sq Ft
429 E Oak Orchard StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1712248
Single Family Residence4 weeks
Active
17 photos
$169,900
$89,421/acre
1.9 acres
4050 Hoffman RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1712306
Unimproved Land4 weeks
Active
11 photos
$59,900
$19,967/acre
3 acres
4020 B Salt Works RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1694973
Land11 weeks

View results from:

Fair Housing Notice

Market Overview — Shelby, NY

Showing Shelby, NY

Property type

ResidentialCommercial

Transaction

For SaleFor Lease

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

$153,950
Median Listing Price: 41
Median Days on EXIT Realty: 1,436
Median Sq Ft: $101
Median Price per Sq Ft

Compare

Compare Shelby, NY to another area

Median price, days on market and size comparison by area
Area	Median Listing Price	Median Days on EXIT Realty	Median Sq Ft	Median Price per Sq Ft	Actions
Shelby, NY	$153,950	41	1,436	$101

Market Composition

What's on the market

80%Residential12 active
20%Land3 active

Active listings by price

Under $200K67% · 8
$200K-$400K33% · 4

Thinking of selling?

EXIT Realty’s Shelby agents know these numbers street by street — and bring the insight and negotiating experience to turn them into your sale price.

Sell a home in Shelby

Nearby Schools

Elementary 7

Clifford H Wise Middle School
Medina, NY · 1.2 mi away
Oak Orchard Primary School
Medina, NY · 1.4 mi away
Warren P Towne Primary School
Medina, NY · 2.3 mi away
Middleport Elementary School
Middleport, NY · 3.9 mi away
Lyndonville Elementary School
Lyndonville, NY · 9.0 mi away
Oakfield Alabama Elementary
Oakfield, NY · 10.1 mi away
Albion Elementary Pta
Albion, NY · 11.2 mi away

Secondary 6

Medina Junior-Senior High School
Medina, NY · 1.1 mi away
Iroquois Job Corps
Medina, NY · 3.9 mi away
Lyndonville Central School
Lyndonville, NY · 8.9 mi away
Oakfield Alabama Central School
Oakfield, NY · 10.1 mi away
Albion Middle School
Albion, NY · 10.9 mi away
Charles D'Amico High School
Albion, NY · 11.0 mi away

Other schools 7

Medina Central School District
Medina, NY · 1.1 mi away
Orleans Niagara Boces
Medina, NY · 1.9 mi away
Orleans County Christian School
Medina, NY · 1.9 mi away
Orleans County Christian School
Medina, NY · 2.7 mi away
Lyndonville Central School
Lyndonville, NY · 8.9 mi away
Gaines Country Preschool
Albion, NY · 9.7 mi away
Albion Central School District
Albion, NY · 11.1 mi away

Shelby, NY Real Estate Listings

Shelby, NY Real Estate Listings

4095 Taylor Hill RoadAlbion, NY 14411#B1719364

1207 S Main StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1718780

706 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1691908

916 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1714478

1209 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1713482

19 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1711410

11024 Furness ParkwayShelby, NY 14103#R1708335

580 East AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1701934

1340 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1698458

362 South AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1668904

60 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1690801

15 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#R1702828

429 E Oak Orchard StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1712248

4050 Hoffman RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1712306

4020 B Salt Works RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1694973

4095 Taylor Hill RoadAlbion, NY 14411#B1719364

1207 S Main StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1718780

706 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1691908

916 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1714478

1209 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1713482

19 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1711410

11024 Furness ParkwayShelby, NY 14103#R1708335

580 East AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1701934

1340 West AvenueShelby, NY 14103#B1698458

362 South AvenueShelby, NY 14103#R1668904

60 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#B1690801

15 Lakewood VillageShelby, NY 14103#R1702828

429 E Oak Orchard StreetShelby, NY 14103#B1712248

4050 Hoffman RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1712306

4020 B Salt Works RoadShelby, NY 14103#B1694973

Market Overview — Shelby, NY

Area Average

Compare

Market Composition

What's on the market

Active listings by price

Nearby Schools

Elementary 7

Secondary 6

Other schools 7