Starkey, NY Real Estate Listings

13 real estate listings match this search criteria near Starkey.

Active
45 photos
$237,000
4 bd, 2 ba, 1,560 Sq Ft
6014 Old Lake RoadStarkey, NY 14878#R1718060
Single Family Residence6 days
Active
50 photos
$860,000
3 bd, 3.5 ba, 2,888 Sq Ft
120 Starkey Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1715221
Single Family Residence2 weeks
Active
16 photos
$165,000
5 bd, 2 ba, 2,592 Sq Ft
25 Bridge Street 1Starkey, NY 14837#R1714129
Duplex2 weeks
Active
40 photos
$449,900
1 bd, 1 ba, 436 Sq Ft
4738 Turkey Run RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1708532
Single Family Residence5 weeks
Active
25 photos
$349,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 712 Sq Ft
4872 Oak RdStarkey, NY 14837#R1689658
Single Family Residence3 months
Active
47 photos
$249,900
4 bd, 2 ba, 2,118 Sq Ft
14 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1683178
Single Family Residence4 months
Active
25 photos
$619,000
2 bd, 1.5 ba, 900 Sq Ft
4098 Squaw Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1677413
Single Family Residence5 months
Active
50 photos
$3,195,000
5 bd, 4 ba, 5,740 Sq Ft
4924 Basswood RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1674061
Single Family Residence5 months
Active
46 photos
$899,000
4 bd, 2 ba, 1,890 Sq Ft
8 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1687207
Single Family Residence4 months
Active
13 photos
$1,495,000
4 bd, 4 ba, 2,776 Sq Ft
5 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1696823
Single Family Residence12 weeks
Active
47 photos
$199,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 980 Sq Ft
337 Dundee Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1706599
Mobile Home7 weeks
Active
50 photos
$1,395,000
3 bd, 2.5 ba, 3,584 Sq Ft
164 N Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1709675
Single Family Residence5 weeks
Active
21 photos
$199,900
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 2,378 Sq Ft
31 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1694522
Single Family Residence3 months

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS. Real estate listings held by firms other than EXIT Realty, are marked with the IDX logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker’s Firm Name.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is deemed reliable by is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

© 2026 CNYIS, Inc., GENRIS and WNYREIS All rights reserved.

Fair Housing Notice

13 real estate listings match this search criteria near Starkey.

Active
45 photos
$237,000
4 bd, 2 ba, 1,560 Sq Ft
6014 Old Lake RoadStarkey, NY 14878#R1718060
Single Family Residence6 days
Active
50 photos
$860,000
3 bd, 3.5 ba, 2,888 Sq Ft
120 Starkey Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1715221
Single Family Residence2 weeks
Active
16 photos
$165,000
5 bd, 2 ba, 2,592 Sq Ft
25 Bridge Street 1Starkey, NY 14837#R1714129
Duplex2 weeks
Active
40 photos
$449,900
1 bd, 1 ba, 436 Sq Ft
4738 Turkey Run RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1708532
Single Family Residence5 weeks
Active
25 photos
$349,000
2 bd, 1 ba, 712 Sq Ft
4872 Oak RdStarkey, NY 14837#R1689658
Single Family Residence3 months
Active
47 photos
$249,900
4 bd, 2 ba, 2,118 Sq Ft
14 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1683178
Single Family Residence4 months
Active
25 photos
$619,000
2 bd, 1.5 ba, 900 Sq Ft
4098 Squaw Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1677413
Single Family Residence5 months
Active
50 photos
$3,195,000
5 bd, 4 ba, 5,740 Sq Ft
4924 Basswood RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1674061
Single Family Residence5 months
Active
46 photos
$899,000
4 bd, 2 ba, 1,890 Sq Ft
8 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1687207
Single Family Residence4 months
Active
13 photos
$1,495,000
4 bd, 4 ba, 2,776 Sq Ft
5 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1696823
Single Family Residence12 weeks
Active
47 photos
$199,000
3 bd, 2 ba, 980 Sq Ft
337 Dundee Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1706599
Mobile Home7 weeks
Active
50 photos
$1,395,000
3 bd, 2.5 ba, 3,584 Sq Ft
164 N Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1709675
Single Family Residence5 weeks
Active
21 photos
$199,900
4 bd, 1.5 ba, 2,378 Sq Ft
31 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1694522
Single Family Residence3 months

Fair Housing Notice

Market Overview — Starkey, NY

Showing Starkey, NY

Property type

ResidentialCommercial

Transaction

For SaleFor Lease

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

$449,900
Median Listing Price: 90
Median Days on EXIT Realty: 2,118
Median Sq Ft: $390
Median Price per Sq Ft

Compare

Compare Starkey, NY to another area

Median price, days on market and size comparison by area
Area	Median Listing Price	Median Days on EXIT Realty	Median Sq Ft	Median Price per Sq Ft	Actions
Starkey, NY	$449,900	90	2,118	$390

Market Composition

What's on the market

63%Residential15 active
29%Land7 active
4%Commercial Lease1 active
4%Commercial1 active

Active listings by price

Under $200K27% · 4
$200K-$400K20% · 3
$400K-$600K7% · 1
$600K-$800K7% · 1
$800K-$1M13% · 2
Over $1M27% · 4

Thinking of selling?

EXIT Realty’s Starkey agents know these numbers street by street — and bring the insight and negotiating experience to turn them into your sale price.

Sell a home in Starkey

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Dundee Elementary School
Dundee, NY · 2.6 mi away
St. Michael School
Penn Yan, NY · 11.0 mi away
Penn Yan Elementary School
Penn Yan, NY · 11.5 mi away
South Seneca Elementary School
Interlaken, NY · 11.7 mi away
Watkins Glen Elementary School
Watkins Glen, NY · 11.7 mi away
B C Cate Elementary School
Montour Falls, NY · 14.3 mi away
Romulus Central School
Romulus, NY · 15.4 mi away
Enfield School
Ithaca, NY · 16.1 mi away

Secondary 5

Dundee Central School
Dundee, NY · 2.6 mi away
South Seneca High School
Ovid, NY · 10.8 mi away
Watkins Glen Central School District
Watkins Glen, NY · 11.5 mi away
Watkins Glen Central School District High School
Watkins Glen, NY · 11.6 mi away
Hammerstone School
Trumansburg, NY · 16.1 mi away

Other schools 7

Piece of Country
Hector, NY · 5.6 mi away
Crystal Valley Christian School
Dundee, NY · 8.1 mi away
Penn Yan Academy
Penn Yan, NY · 11.3 mi away
Watkins Glen Middle School
Watkins Glen, NY · 11.3 mi away
Emmanuel Baptist Academy
Penn Yan, NY · 11.4 mi away
Penn Yan Central School District
Penn Yan, NY · 11.5 mi away
Bradford Central School
Bradford, NY · 14.7 mi away

Starkey, NY Real Estate Listings

Starkey, NY Real Estate Listings

6014 Old Lake RoadStarkey, NY 14878#R1718060

120 Starkey Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1715221

25 Bridge Street 1Starkey, NY 14837#R1714129

4738 Turkey Run RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1708532

4872 Oak RdStarkey, NY 14837#R1689658

14 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1683178

4098 Squaw Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1677413

4924 Basswood RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1674061

8 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1687207

5 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1696823

337 Dundee Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1706599

164 N Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1709675

31 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1694522

6014 Old Lake RoadStarkey, NY 14878#R1718060

120 Starkey Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1715221

25 Bridge Street 1Starkey, NY 14837#R1714129

4738 Turkey Run RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1708532

4872 Oak RdStarkey, NY 14837#R1689658

14 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1683178

4098 Squaw Point RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1677413

4924 Basswood RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1674061

8 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1687207

5 Red Cedar Falls LaneStarkey, NY 14837#R1696823

337 Dundee Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1706599

164 N Glenora RoadStarkey, NY 14837#R1709675

31 Hollister StreetStarkey, NY 14837#R1694522

Market Overview — Starkey, NY

Area Average

Compare

Market Composition

What's on the market

Active listings by price

Nearby Schools

Elementary 8

Secondary 5

Other schools 7