Active
33 photos$2,690,000
4 bd, 2.5 ba, 2,289 Sq Ft
7 Wheeler RoadShelter Island, NY 11965#1048489
Listing courtesy of World Prop Intl Sea to Sky
Sell with EXIT Realty · Shelter Island, NY
Sell your home in Shelter Island, NY
See how the Shelter Island market is moving and connect with an experienced EXIT Realty agent who can price, market, and negotiate your sale — a trusted name in real estate since 1996.
Your seller's market report
What your Shelter Island sale looks like right now
A read on the Shelter Island, NY market built from live MLS listing data — the numbers an agent would walk you through first.
Across 22 homes for sale in Shelter Island, the median asking price is $2,897,500 and the average sale takes 124 days.
That's the market, not your home — what yours is worth depends on the street, the condition, and the timing. An EXIT agent can run those numbers with you.
Get a real price opinionMedian list price of active MLS listings in Shelter Island, NY — not an estimate of your home's value.
Local market data
Inside the Shelter Island market
Real numbers to help you price and time your sale with confidence.
Market pace
- Fast
- Moderate
- Unhurried
Homes are taking their time to sell — pricing sharp from day one matters more than ever.
Based on the average days on market for active listings in Shelter Island, NY.
- $2,897,500
- Median list price
- 22
- Homes for sale
- 124
- Avg. days on market
- $824/sq ft
- Median price / sq ft
- 3,369 Sq Ft
- Median home size
What's on the market in Shelter Island
- 67%Residential22 active
- 24%For Lease8 active
- 9%Land3 active
Where the asking prices sit
- $800K-$1M5% · 1
- Over $1M95% · 21
Market figures are computed from active MLS listing data for Shelter Island, NY and refresh as listings change. They describe the market, not any individual property.
Your competition
Homes like yours on the market in Shelter Island
What buyers comparing your home are looking at right now.
Showing single-family homes in Shelter Island.
- Active50 photos
$1,350,000
2 bd, 2 ba, 1,464 Sq Ft
11 Jaspa RoadShelter Island, NY 11964#1049777
Listing courtesy of RustyCap O Inc
- Active25 photos
$2,200,000
4 bd, 2.5 ba, 1,994 Sq Ft
11 Prospect AvenueShelter Island Heights, NY 11965#1022345
Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
- Active36 photos
$3,795,000
5 bd, 5 ba, 3,072 Sq Ft
5 Sea Gull RoadShelter Island, NY 11964#1016596
Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
- Active49 photos
$3,290,000
5 bd, 4.5 ba, 6,106 Sq Ft
43 Gardiners Bay DriveShelter Island, NY 11964#1012419
Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
- Active30 photos
$5,000,000
4 bd, 5.5 ba, 4,000 Sq Ft
11 Sunnyside AvenueShelter Island, NY 11964#990118
Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Recent results
Recently sold in Shelter Island
Homes near you that found their buyer.
Sold$1,500,000
5 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,845 Sq Ft
5 Spring Garden Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY
Sold$1,900,000
4 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,800 Sq Ft
31A Dickerson Drive, Shelter Island, NY
Sold$668,000
3 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,400 Sq Ft
53 Mapleton Avenue, Shelter Island, NY
Sold$1,500,000
4 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,750 Sq Ft
26 Country Club Drive, Shelter Island, NY
Sold$895,000
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,200 Sq Ft
16 Sunshine Road, Shelter Island, NY
Sold$1,590,000
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,260 Sq Ft
100 S Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved
Fair Housing Notice
Fair Housing Notice The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (IDX) program of the Brooklyn Board of Realtors. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 Brooklyn MLS. All Rights Reserved.
Fair Housing Notice
Fair Housing NoticeThinking about listing?
Skip the guesswork — find out what your home would actually command in today's Shelter Island market.
EXIT Realty Stars, serving Shelter Island
About Shelter Island
Nearby schools for Shelter Island, NY (approximate).
Nearby Schools
Elementary 5
Sag Harbor Elementary School
Southold Elementary School
Cutchogue East Elementary School
Peconic Community School
Our Lady of Mercy Elementary School
Secondary 5
Shelter Island High School
Pierson Middle High School
Southold Junior Senior High School
Ross School
East Hampton Union Free School District
Other schools 10
Shelter Island School
Greenport Ufsd
Sag Harbor Union Free School District
Our Sons and Daughters
Ross Lower School
Ross School
Hayground School
Bridgehampton School
CDCH Charter School
Mattituck Cutchogue Ufsd
Simple, guided, proven
How selling in Shelter Island works
Step 1: Connect with a local agent
Tell us about your home and we'll match you with an EXIT Realty agent who knows the Shelter Island market.
Step 2: Get a personalized valuation
Your agent prepares a comparative market analysis and recommends a pricing strategy built for today's market.
Step 3: Market with impact
Professional photography, online syndication, and targeted promotion reach the right buyers, faster.
Step 4: Sell and close with confidence
Your agent negotiates the strongest offer and guides you all the way through to closing day.
The number that matters
What is your home actually worth?
These figures describe the Shelter Island market — not your home. A local EXIT Realty agent will prepare a precise valuation from comparable sales, your home's condition, and what buyers are paying right now. No obligation.
Tell us a little about your home. A local agent from EXIT Realty Stars will reach out with a personalized market analysis — no obligation.
In your corner, locally
Your local EXIT Realty offices
These EXIT Realty offices serve Shelter Island. When you're ready, reach out and let an agent take it from here.
EXIT Realty Stars
66A Jerusalem AveHicksville, NY 11081 · 19.2 mi
Sobdar (David) Chandio, Broker of Record
Serving Hicksville and surrounding areas
EXIT Realty Island Elite
870 Love LaneMattituck, NY 11952 · 19.3 mi
Jason Furnari, Broker of Record
Serving Mattituck and surrounding areas
EXIT Realty Liberty
40 Peconic AveRiverhead, NY 11901 · 32.6 mi
Maureen Klersy, Broker of Record
Serving Riverhead and surrounding areas — our team speaks Spanish
The EXIT advantage
Why sell with EXIT Realty?
Agents invested in your success
EXIT Realty's residual income model keeps our agents focused on results — your sale, not just the next deal.
Local expertise, global network
A local expert markets your home, backed by thousands of EXIT associates across North America.
Comprehensive marketing
Professional photography, online syndication, and targeted promotion put your home in front of ready buyers.